What's Better in British Columbia: A Charity or a Not-for-profit?

When deciding to start an organization in British Columbia (BC) generally, or Vancouver specifically, understanding the difference between a charity and a not-for-profit organization (NPO) is essential. 

While both are designed to serve the community, the structure, tax benefits, and regulatory obligations of each differ significantly. 

This guide will walk you through these distinctions and help you make the right decision for your cause.

What’s the Main Difference Between a Charity and a Not-for-profit?

Both charities and not-for-profits serve public interests, but they differ primarily in their purpose and tax treatment. In BC, the primary differences include:

• Charity: A charity must have specific charitable purposes (such as advancing education, relieving poverty, or supporting religious activities) and operate to benefit the public. Charities are eligible for special tax benefits, including issuing tax-deductible donation receipts.
• Not-for-profit (NPO): An NPO can serve a broader range of purposes, including cultural, social, or recreational, but cannot issue tax-deductible receipts. The income of NPOs cannot benefit any members or stakeholders.

Legal Structure and Registration

In British Columbia, charities must be registered with the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) to issue official donation receipts. The CRA ensures that charities operate under strict rules and meet the requirements for charitable registration, such as having charitable purposes and conducting activities exclusively for charitable goals.

NPOs, on the other hand, do not require CRA registration for tax exemption, though they still need to follow certain rules to maintain their tax-exempt status. They are often formed as societies under the British Columbia Societies Act or as Not-for-Profit Corporations under the CNCA. Unlike charities, NPOs cannot benefit from tax-deductible donations but still enjoy tax-exempt status on income if they meet the necessary conditions.

Tax Benefits

The tax benefits available to charities in BC are one of the most significant advantages of choosing this structure. Charities can issue tax receipts to donors, which can reduce the donor's taxable income. This incentive often helps charities raise more funds from individual and corporate donors.

NPOs, however, cannot issue these receipts, making it potentially harder to attract large donations. Still, NPOs are exempt from paying income taxes on their revenues if they meet the required conditions, but they don’t offer tax benefits to donors.

Purpose and Operations

In British Columbia, charities are limited to charitable purposes as defined by the CRA, such as:

• Relieving poverty
• Advancing education
• Advancing religion
• Benefiting the community in a way the law regards as charitable (e.g., supporting public health, the environment, or arts)

NPOs in BC, on the other hand, have more flexibility. They can pursue recreational, social, or cultural objectives and are not restricted to charitable causes. For example, a sports club or a local theater group could be set up as an NPO.

Fundraising and Revenue Generation

For charities in BC, donations are a key source of funding. The ability to issue tax-deductible donation receipts is a significant advantage for attracting individual and corporate donors. Charities may also receive grants from governments or private foundations specifically allocated to charitable purposes.

NPOs in BC may still receive donations, but without the tax-deductible benefit, they typically rely more on membership fees, event revenue, and sponsorships. NPOs may engage in some business activities, but these must be aligned with their purpose and not primarily aim at making profits.

Accountability and Compliance

The CRA closely monitors registered charities in BC to ensure they follow strict guidelines, particularly regarding how donations are spent. Charities are required to file an annual T3010 form with detailed financial information, which is made available to the public.

NPOs, while less regulated, still have reporting obligations. They must maintain proper books and records and file annual financial reports under the BC Societies Act. Additionally, NPOs must ensure they remain tax-exempt by not distributing income to members.

Comparing Core Purposes and Objectives

Charities address social problems through their four permitted purposes. Relief of poverty includes food banks and housing assistance programmes.

Advancement of education covers schools, libraries, and research institutions. Advancement of religion includes churches and religious education programmes.

‍

Not-for-profit organizations pursue diverse social welfare goals beyond the four charitable categories. They can advocate for policy changes or provide recreational services.

NPOs often serve specific communities or interest groups. Charities must demonstrate broader public benefit in their work.

Both types of organizations contribute to social welfare but through different approaches and legal frameworks.

Should You Start a Charity or a Not-for-profit in British Columbia?

The choice between starting a charity or a not-for-profit organization in BC depends on the nature of your mission and your funding strategy. If your primary goal aligns with charitable purposes and you plan to raise funds through donations, a charity may be the better choice because of the tax benefits for donors. However, this comes with greater regulatory oversight and a more restricted operational focus.

If your organization is more focused on community activities, recreation, or cultural pursuits and does not need to rely on large donations, an NPO might be a better fit. NPOs enjoy more operational flexibility and face less stringent oversight.

Key Takeaways

• Charities in BC must serve charitable purposes and offer tax-deductible receipts, but they face stricter regulatory requirements.
• NPOs offer greater flexibility in their activities but do not benefit from the ability to issue tax receipts, limiting their fundraising capabilities.
• Both charities and NPOs enjoy tax-exempt status on income if they comply with legal requirements.
• Choosing the right structure for your organization depends on your mission, funding needs, and willingness to adhere to specific regulatory guidelines.

Choosing whether to start a charity or a not-for-profit in British Columbia or Vancouver involves careful consideration of your organization's goals, how you plan to raise funds, and your tolerance for regulatory oversight. A charity might be the best fit if your mission aligns with a charitable purpose and you aim to raise significant funds from donors. Alternatively, an NPO provides more flexibility in activities while still serving the community.

Legal Status and Regulatory Requirements in British Columbia

Understanding legal status and regulatory requirements helps you determine which structure works best for your organization. Charities must register with the Canada Revenue Agency, while not-for-profits can incorporate provincially or federally with different governance rules.

Charitable Status and Registration

Charitable organizations in British Columbia must register with the Canada Revenue Agency to become a registered charity. This process requires meeting strict charitable purposes under Canadian law.

The CRA reviews applications carefully. Your organization must show it will relieve poverty, advance education, advance religion, or benefit the community in ways the law considers charitable.

Registration requirements include:

• Detailed governing documents
• Operating plans and budgets
• Board member information
• Proof of charitable activities

Once registered, charities receive a charitable registration number. This number allows them to issue official donation receipts to donors.

Registered charities must file annual T3010 returns with the CRA. These returns show detailed financial information and become public records.

Incorporation and Governance Structures

Not-for-profit organizations in British Columbia can incorporate as societies under the BC Societies Act. Incorporation creates a legal entity separate from its members.

Societies must have at least five founding members. They need a constitution that states their purposes and bylaws that explain how they operate.

Key governance requirements include:

• Board of directors (minimum three people)
• Annual general meetings
• Member voting rights
• Financial record keeping

The BC Corporate Registry oversees societies. Organizations must file annual reports and pay small fees to maintain good standing.

Charities can also incorporate as societies in BC. However, they still need separate charitable registration from the CRA to issue tax receipts.

Provincial vs. Federal Incorporation

Organizations can choose between provincial incorporation in BC or federal incorporation under the Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act.

Provincial incorporation under the BC Societies Act works well for organizations operating mainly in British Columbia. The process costs less and takes less time than federal incorporation.

Federal incorporation creates a not-for-profit corporation that can operate across Canada. This option suits organizations planning to work in multiple provinces.

Federal not-for-profit corporations follow different rules than BC societies. They use articles of incorporation instead of constitutions and have different governance requirements.

Both provincial societies and federal not-for-profit corporations can apply for charitable status with the CRA. The incorporation choice does not affect eligibility for charitable registration.

Tax Benefits and Financial Considerations

The tax benefits available to charities versus not-for-profits create a significant difference in fundraising potential and financial operations. Charities can issue tax receipts that reduce donors' taxes by 43.7% or more for donations above $200, while NPOs cannot offer this advantage.

Tax Receipts and Donations

Registered charities in British Columbia have a major advantage with donations. We can issue official tax receipts to donors through the Canada Revenue Agency registration system.

When donors give more than $200 to our charity, they receive combined federal and BC tax credits worth 43.7% or more of their donation. A $1,000 donation only costs the donor about $563 after tax savings.

Key Benefits for Charity Donors:

• Tax receipts reduce taxable income
• Higher savings on larger donations
• Immediate tax benefits in the same year

Not-for-profit organizations cannot issue these tax receipts. Our NPO donors receive no tax benefits for their contributions, making it harder for NPOs to attract large donations from individuals and corporations.

Funding Sources and Grants

Charities and NPOs access different types of funding based on their legal status. We see clear differences in available revenue streams between these two structures.

Charity Funding Sources:

• Tax-deductible donations from individuals
• Corporate charitable giving programs
• Government grants for charitable purposes
• Private foundation grants
• Fundraising events

NPO Funding Sources:

• Membership fees
• Event revenue and ticket sales
• Corporate sponsorships
• Non-charitable grants
• Business activities aligned with purpose

Charities often receive larger individual donations because of the tax benefits we can offer. NPOs typically rely more on membership fees and event revenue to fund their operations.

Financial Disclosure Requirements

Both charities and NPOs face different financial reporting obligations that affect our operations and public transparency.

Registered charities must file an annual T3010 form with the Canada Revenue Agency. This detailed financial report becomes public information.

We must show exactly how we spend donated funds and prove our charitable activities. NPOs file annual financial reports under the BC Societies Act.

These reports are less detailed than charity filings. We still must maintain proper financial records and avoid distributing income to members.

Charity Requirements:

• Public T3010 annual returns
• Detailed spending breakdowns
• Strict CRA oversight
• Regular compliance reviews

NPO Requirements:

• BC Societies Act reporting
• Basic financial statements
• Internal record keeping
• Member accountability

Governance, Board Structure, and Operational Management

Both charities and not-for-profits in British Columbia require boards of directors. The key differences lie in regulatory oversight and specific compliance requirements that affect how we structure and manage these organizations.

Role of the Board of Directors

The board of directors serves as the governing body for both charities and not-for-profits in BC. We must ensure boards fulfill their fiduciary duties and strategic oversight responsibilities.

For registered charities, the Canada Revenue Agency closely monitors board activities. Board members must ensure the organization operates exclusively for charitable purposes and cannot receive personal benefits from charity resources.

Not-for-profit boards have more flexibility in their operations. We can pursue broader community goals beyond charitable purposes, but board members still cannot profit from the organization's activities.

Key Board Responsibilities:

• Strategic planning and policy development
• Financial oversight and budgeting
• Executive director hiring and evaluation
• Risk management and compliance

Both structures typically use committee systems. Common committees include governance, finance, and fundraising.

The board must maintain proper meeting minutes and financial records. Charities face stricter documentation requirements due to CRA oversight.

Membership and Bylaws

Bylaws establish the legal framework for how we operate our organizations. Both charities and not-for-profits must file bylaws with BC Registry Services.

Charitable organizations follow bylaws that reflect their charitable purposes. We must ensure all activities align with CRA requirements.

Not-for-profit bylaws offer more flexibility. We can include broader purposes like cultural, recreational, or social activities.

Typical Bylaw Components:

• Membership categories and voting rights
• Board composition and election procedures
• Meeting requirements and quorum rules
• Financial management protocols

Membership structures vary between organizations. Some operate with voting members who elect board members, while others function with appointed boards and no formal membership.

Both structures must hold annual general meetings. We need to report on activities and financial performance to members or the community.

Volunteer Involvement

Volunteers play essential roles in both charities and not-for-profits across British Columbia. We rely on volunteers for program delivery, fundraising, and administrative support.

Charities often attract volunteers motivated by tax-deductible donation benefits. This can make it easier to recruit volunteers for charitable causes.

Not-for-profits focus on volunteers interested in specific community activities or causes. Without tax incentives, we build volunteer engagement through direct program participation.

Volunteer Management Considerations:

• Screening and background checks for sensitive roles
• Training and orientation programs
• Recognition and retention strategies
• Insurance coverage for volunteer activities

Both structures need clear volunteer policies and procedures. We ensure volunteers understand their roles and limitations within the organization.

Effective volunteer coordination bridges the gap between governance and operations. Board members often serve as volunteers while maintaining oversight responsibilities.

Fundraising Strategies and Community Impact

Charities and not-for-profits use different fundraising methods based on their legal structure and tax status. Charities can offer tax receipts to donors, which shapes their fundraising approach compared to not-for-profits that use other incentives.

Charity Fundraising Approaches

Charitable organizations in BC have a major advantage through tax-deductible donation receipts. This benefit attracts larger donations from individuals and corporations who want to reduce their taxable income.

Primary funding sources for charities include:

• Individual donations with tax receipt benefits
• Corporate sponsorships seeking tax deductions
• Government grants for charitable purposes
• Foundation grants specifically for registered charities

Major donor campaigns work well for charities because wealthy donors get significant tax benefits. Corporate partnerships also thrive since businesses can claim charitable donations as tax deductions.

The Community Gaming Grants program distributes $140 million annually to BC charitable organizations. This government funding supports thousands of local charities across the province.

Online fundraising campaigns can be very effective. BC Lottery Corporation's "Spread the Local Love" campaign helps donors double their impact through matching funds.

Charities must follow strict rules about spending donated money. The Canada Revenue Agency monitors these organizations closely and requires detailed annual reporting through T3010 forms.

Not-for-profit Fundraising Methods

Nonprofit organizations face more challenges in fundraising since they cannot issue tax receipts. These groups rely more on membership fees, event revenue, and community support.

Common fundraising methods for not-for-profits:

• Membership dues and fees
• Special events and activities
• Corporate sponsorships without tax benefits
• Product sales aligned with their mission

Community events become crucial fundraising tools. Sports clubs might host tournaments, while arts groups organize performances or exhibitions to generate revenue.

Sponsorship packages work differently for nonprofits. Companies sponsor these organizations for community visibility rather than tax deductions.

Local businesses often support recreational and cultural nonprofits to show community involvement. Grant opportunities exist but are more limited.

Some foundations and government programs support nonprofit activities, especially those focused on community development or cultural initiatives. Volunteer engagement is essential since nonprofits often operate with smaller budgets.

Strong volunteer networks help reduce operational costs while building community connections.

Choosing the Right Structure for Your Purpose

Your organization's mission and funding needs determine whether a charity or non-profit structure works best. We will examine how to evaluate your goals, plan for growth, and understand compliance requirements.

Evaluating Organisational Goals

Charitable purposes include relieving poverty, advancing education, advancing religion, and benefiting the community. If our work fits these categories, we can register as a charity.

Non-profits serve broader purposes. We can focus on cultural activities, sports clubs, or social groups without meeting charitable requirements.

Funding strategy matters most. Charities issue tax receipts that encourage larger donations. Individual donors get tax deductions, making them more likely to give.

Non-profits rely on different revenue sources:

• Membership fees
• Event tickets
• Sponsorships
• Grants (non-charitable)

Consider our target audience. Major donors and foundations often prefer giving to registered charities. Corporate sponsors may support non-profits for marketing benefits.

The non-profit sector includes both structures. Charitable status opens more funding doors.

Long-term Sustainability and Growth

Regulatory requirements affect growth plans. Charities face strict Canada Revenue Agency oversight. We must file detailed T3010 forms annually and keep extensive records.

Non-profits have lighter reporting duties under BC's Societies Act. This means less paperwork but fewer funding opportunities.

Revenue restrictions differ significantly. Charities cannot distribute profits to members or directors. All funds must serve charitable purposes exclusively.

Non-profits also cannot distribute income to members. We have more flexibility in activities and spending.

Expansion considerations:

• Charities can operate across Canada once federally registered
• Non-profits may need separate registrations in other provinces
• International work is easier for registered charities

Staff compensation rules are stricter for charities. We must pay reasonable salaries and document all expenses carefully.

Policy and Compliance Insights

Charity compliance is comprehensive. The CRA monitors how we spend donations and requires public financial disclosure. We lose charitable status if we break rules.

Key charity requirements:

• Spend funds only on charitable activities
• Keep detailed financial records
• File annual returns on time
• Avoid political activities beyond allowed limits

Non-profit compliance is simpler. We file basic reports with BC's Corporate Registry and maintain proper books.

Non-profit requirements:

• Hold annual general meetings
• Keep membership records current
• File annual reports with province
• Maintain tax-exempt status rules

Governance differs between structures. Charities need independent boards with no personal benefit from the organisation. Non-profits can have members who benefit from services.

Risk management varies. Charities face potential CRA audits and public scrutiny. Non-profits have fewer external reviews but still need proper internal controls.

Both structures protect directors from personal liability when following proper procedures.

Conclusion

Choosing between a charity or not-for-profit organization in British Columbia requires careful evaluation of your mission, funding needs, and regulatory preferences. Charities offer powerful fundraising advantages through tax-deductible receipts but come with strict CRA oversight.

Not-for-profits provide greater operational flexibility while maintaining tax-exempt status. The decision depends on whether your organization's goals align with charitable purposes and your willingness to meet compliance requirements.

Sports clubs and cultural groups often thrive as NPOs, while organizations focused on poverty relief or education benefit from charitable status.

At B.I.G. Charity Law Group, we guide organizations through this important decision process. Our expertise in Canadian charity and not-for-profit law ensures you choose the right structure for your mission.

Contact us at dov.goldberg@charitylawgroup.ca or (416) 488-5888 to discuss your specific needs. Visit CharityLawGroup.ca to learn more about our services and schedule your FREE consultation today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Starting an organization in BC involves specific steps and requirements that differ between charities and non-profits. Tax obligations, benefits, and effectiveness also vary based on your organization's structure and purpose.

How do you start a non-profit organization in BC?

Incorporate under the BC Societies Act by filing paperwork with BC Registry Services. You need a unique name, articles of incorporation, bylaws, and at least three founding members over 16. After incorporation, apply for tax-exempt status with the Canada Revenue Agency.

How do you start a charity in BC, Canada?

First incorporate as a society or non-profit corporation, then apply to the Canada Revenue Agency for charitable registration. Your purposes must fit into relieving poverty, advancing education, advancing religion, or benefiting the community. The CRA review process takes several months and requires detailed documentation.

Which charity is most effective in Canada?

Charity effectiveness depends on the specific cause and how we measure impact. Research charity effectiveness using websites like Charity Intelligence Canada, which evaluate organizations based on financial transparency and program results. 

Local BC charities may be most effective for community-specific needs, while national charities might have more resources but less local focus.

What are the benefits of non profit organization in Canada?

Non-profits enjoy tax-exempt status on income, access to grants from government agencies and foundations, volunteer program opportunities, and public credibility that signals community benefit rather than personal profit.

What is the difference between nonprofit and not for profit in Canada?

In Canada, these terms mean the same thing - organizations that don't distribute profits to members. The key distinction is between registered charities (which can issue tax receipts) and regular non-profits (which cannot).

Do not for profits pay taxes in Canada?

Not-for-profit organizations don't pay income tax if they meet CRA conditions and use income only for stated purposes. They may pay GST/HST on taxable supplies and property taxes, though some exemptions exist. Income from unrelated activities may be taxable.