How to Report Suspected Non-Compliance by Charities in Canada

Ever heard of the phrase "charity begins at home"? Well, it certainly does, but what if a charity isn't exactly playing by the rules? As citizens, we have a responsibility to ensure that organizations registered as charities are doing what they're supposed to: helping others, not cheating the system.

If you suspect a registered charity isn't following regulations, you can report your concerns to the Canada Revenue Agency through their official reporting system for suspected non-compliance. The CRA's Charities Directorate oversees these organizations and investigates potential violations.

Knowing how to spot warning signs and properly report suspected issues helps maintain trust in Canada's charitable sector. This guide explains the process, from recognizing red flags to understanding what happens after you file a report, and shares important considerations before taking action.

Understanding Non-Compliance in Registered Charities

Non-compliance happens when registered charities fail to meet legal obligations under the Income Tax Act or operate outside their charitable purposes. Even unintentional violations can lead to serious penalties from the Canada Revenue Agency.

Common Types of Non-Compliance

Improper fundraising practices are frequent violations among registered charities. This includes misleading donors about fund use or not providing proper receipts.

Conducting non-charitable activities is another concern. Charities must focus on their stated purposes and cannot engage in unrelated business activities.

Providing private benefits to directors or third parties breaks charity regulations. This happens when charities pay excessive salaries or provide financial benefits to connected individuals.

Inadequate books and records create compliance problems. Charities must keep detailed financial records and documentation of their activities.

False or improper receipting occurs when charities issue donation receipts incorrectly. This includes receipting for services, goods, or non-qualifying amounts.

Legal Framework Governing Charities

The Income Tax Act is the main legal framework for registered charities in Canada. It defines charitable activities and sets operational requirements.

Registered charities must operate only for charitable purposes. These include relief of poverty, advancement of education, advancement of religion, and other community benefits.

Provincial laws also apply to charity operations. Charities must follow both federal tax regulations and provincial requirements.

The Canada Revenue Agency's Charities Directorate enforces these rules. They can audit charities, impose penalties, and revoke charitable status for serious violations.

Potential Consequences for Charities

Administrative penalties are common for minor violations. These include fines or requirements to file extra documentation with the CRA.

Suspension of receipting privileges prevents charities from issuing official donation receipts. This affects fundraising and donor relationships.

Revocation of charitable status is the most severe penalty. Charities lose their tax-exem

pt status and ability to issue receipts permanently.

Tax penalties may apply to income from unrelated business activities. Charities could face large tax bills on non-charitable income.

Public disclosure of compliance issues appears on the CRA website. This can damage reputation and affect future fundraising and support.

Identifying Signs of Non-Compliance

Recognizing warning signs helps spot when charities may be breaking rules. Key red flags include poor record-keeping, incorrect receipts, and activities that do not match their charitable purpose.

What to Look Out For:

Here are some red flags that might signal a charity isn't following the rules:

1. Improper Fundraising: Is the charity using shady tactics to get donations? This could include aggressive or deceptive methods to pressure individuals into giving.
2. Non-Charitable Activities:  Is the charity straying from its stated mission and engaging in activities unrelated to helping others? This might indicate a lack of focus or mismanagement of resources.
3. False Receipts: Giving out receipts for donations that weren't actually made is a serious offense. It not only deceives donors but also raises questions about the charity's integrity.
4. Private Benefits: Watch out for instances where directors or other parties associated with the charity receive perks or benefits they shouldn't. This could include excessive salaries, personal use of assets, or other forms of preferential treatment.
5. Misappropriating Funds: Using donation money for personal gain.
6. Lack of Control:  Charities operating outside of Canada without proper oversight may raise concerns about accountability and transparency. It's essential to verify that the charity adheres to relevant regulations, regardless of its geographic scope.
7. Running an Unrelated Business: Doing things that aren't related to their charitable purpose.

How to Report Suspicions:

If you suspect a charity of wrongdoing, you can report it through the "Report a lead on suspected tax cheating in Canada" program. Here's what you should include:

1. Charity Details: Name of the charity and, if possible, its registration number.
2. Evidence: Provide as much detailed information as you can to back up your suspicions.
3. Documentation: If you have any documents that support your claims, include those too.

Your Privacy Matters:You can report suspicions anonymously if you prefer. But if you do decide to share your identity, it will be kept confidential. Just remember, once you've submitted a report, you won't receive updates on the investigation. The actions taken by the Charities Directorate are made public only if a charity is revoked, annulled, suspended, or penalized as a result.
‍
Why It's Important:Charities play a crucial role in helping those in need. When they operate dishonestly, it not only undermines public trust but also takes away resources from legitimate causes. By reporting suspicions of non-compliance, you're helping to ensure that charities are doing what they're supposed to: making a positive impact on the world.

How to Report Suspected Non-Compliance to the CRA

The Canada Revenue Agency offers a formal process through their Leads Program for reporting suspected violations by registered charities. You must provide specific information and can choose to remain anonymous when submitting concerns to the Charities Directorate.

Steps to Submit a Report

Report suspected charity non-compliance through the CRA's official Leads Program. This system lets you submit information about registered charities that may not meet regulatory requirements.

Visit the CRA website and go to the "Report suspected non-compliance by registered charities" section. You can also use the general tax cheating reporting system.

The online submission form guides you through each required field. Complete all mandatory sections before submitting your report.

Alternative reporting methods include:

• Calling the Charities Directorate at 1-800-267-2384
• Submitting written documentation by mail

Choose the method that works best for your situation. The online system processes reports faster than other methods.

Information Required for Reporting

The CRA needs specific details to investigate your concerns. Provide relevant information to help them determine if non-compliance has occurred.

Essential information to include:

‍

Common non-compliance issues to report:

• Improper fundraising activities
• Non-charitable activities
• False tax receipts
• Private benefits to directors
• Misuse of charitable funds

Be as specific as possible. General complaints without supporting details make investigation difficult for the Charities Directorate.

Confidentiality and Anonymity

You can submit your report anonymously through the Leads Program. The CRA protects your identity if you request confidentiality.

Your personal information stays protected under federal privacy laws. The CRA does not share your identity with the charity you are reporting.

Providing your contact information helps the investigation. The Charities Directorate may need to ask follow-up questions or request more evidence.

Benefits of providing contact details:

• Faster investigation process
• Ability to provide additional evidence
• Updates on investigation status

Consider your privacy concerns and the benefits of direct communication with CRA investigators.

What Happens After You File a Report

The CRA follows a structured process to review reports about charity non-compliance. They may take different enforcement actions depending on what they find during their investigation.

The CRA's Review and Investigation Process

The Charities Directorate receives your report and assigns it to trained staff for review. Staff look at the information you provided and check it against the charity's records.

The CRA may start an audit if they find serious concerns. During an audit, they examine the charity's books and activities closely.

They check if the charity follows the Income Tax Act rules. The investigation can take several months or longer, depending on the complexity and the information needed.

The CRA keeps your identity private during this process. They do not tell the charity who made the report unless required by law.

Staff may contact you for more details or documents about your report. They might ask for clarification about what you observed.

Possible CRA Responses and Outcomes

The CRA can take different actions based on what they discover:

No Action Required

• No problems found with the charity
• Your report did not show actual rule breaking
• The charity already fixed the issues

Education and Guidance

• Letters explaining proper rules
• Training for charity leaders
• Requirements for better record keeping

Formal Penalties

• Financial penalties for violations
• Suspension of charity status
• Complete removal of charitable status

The CRA publishes information about penalties and suspensions on their website. You can check there to see if action was taken against the charity you reported.

The CRA will not contact you about the final outcome unless they need you as a witness in legal proceedings.

When and How to Contact the Charities Directorate

The Charities Directorate provides several ways to reach their representatives for help with charity compliance matters. Contact them directly if you need guidance on specific situations or if online resources do not answer your concerns.

Contact Methods and Resources

The Canada Revenue Agency's Charities Directorate offers several ways to help with charity-related questions. Their client service representatives answer calls Monday to Friday from 8 am to 5 pm Eastern time, except on statutory holidays.

Phone Contact:

• Main line: 1-800-267-2384
• Available for general inquiries and guidance

Online Resources:

• My Business Account (MyBA) for filing returns
• Represent a Client system for authorized representatives
• Online application system for charity registration

The Charities Directorate offers general information about registered charities. They guide users through the online registration process.

Representatives explain how to issue official donation receipts. Staff help with completing the annual information return using Form T3010.

They also guide you on changing your charity's legal name, purposes, or activities.

Situations Requiring Direct Communication

Contact the Charities Directorate directly when you need guidance that goes beyond general information. Call them if you are unsure about compliance requirements for your situation.

When to Call:

• Questions about proper receipt issuance
• Guidance on changing charity details
• Help with Form T3010 completion
• Clarification on regulatory requirements

Contact them during service disruptions, such as Canada Post delays. They can suggest alternative filing methods for your T3010 deadline.

Representatives answer questions about your charity's specific circumstances. They provide personalized guidance that online resources may not cover.

If you are not satisfied with the service, you can make a formal complaint through the Canada Revenue Agency's complaint process.

Key Considerations and Best Practices for Whistleblowers

When reporting suspected non-compliance by registered charities to the CRA, approach the situation carefully and responsibly. Understanding your legal position helps protect you and ensures your complaint receives proper attention.

Avoiding Bad Faith or Frivolous Complaints

File complaints only when you have legitimate concerns backed by real evidence. Frivolous complaints waste valuable resources that could help genuine cases.

What constitutes a valid complaint:

• Documented evidence of wrongdoing
• Specific examples with dates and details
• Clear violations of charitable regulations
• Financial records or receipts that support your concerns

Gather as much detailed information as possible before reporting. Include charity names, registration numbers, and specific examples of suspected violations.

Vague complaints without supporting evidence rarely lead to meaningful investigations. Avoid making reports based on personal disputes or disagreements with charity policies.

The CRA investigates regulatory violations, not internal management decisions you might dislike.

Documentation you should collect:

• Financial statements showing irregularities
• Communications proving inappropriate activities
• Witness statements from other concerned parties
• Photos or videos of questionable practices

Legal Protections and Potential Risks

You have the right to report suspected charity violations anonymously. The CRA keeps your personal information confidential during their investigation.

Your protections include:

• Anonymous reporting options
• Confidential treatment of your identity
• No obligation to provide personal contact information
• Protection from charity retaliation through legal channels

However, making false accusations can have legal consequences. If you knowingly provide false information, you might face defamation claims or other legal action from the charity involved.

You will not receive updates about the investigation once you submit your report. The CRA only makes results public if they revoke, suspend, or penalize a registered charity.

The best protection is to ensure your complaints are truthful and based on solid evidence before you file them.

Conclusion

Reporting suspected non-compliance helps protect Canada's charitable sector. When you file a report with the CRA's Charities Directorate, you help maintain public trust in registered charities.

The process is straightforward and confidential. You can submit leads online or call the Charities Directorate directly.

Provide specific details about the suspected violations to help CRA investigators assess the situation properly.

Charity compliance matters require careful handling. Charity Law Group understands the complexities involved when charities face compliance issues or investigations.

Book a FREE CALL with us to learn how our legal expertise can help your organisation navigate CRA requirements and maintain good standing.

Frequently Asked Questions

The CRA has specific ways to report charity problems and apply penalties for rule breaking. People can contact different government offices depending on their situation and location.

How do I report a charity in Canada?

You can report suspected charity non-compliance through the CRA's online system called "Report a lead on suspected tax cheating in Canada." This covers most charity rule violations.

Try talking directly to the charity about your concerns first. Most registered charities respond well to questions and may have good reasons for their actions.

If direct contact does not work, submit your report online to the CRA. Include details about improper fundraising, non-charitable activities, false receipts, or private benefits given to directors.

You can also call the Charities Directorate at 1-800-267-2384 with questions about the reporting process.

What are the sanctions of charities in CRA?

The CRA can apply penalties and suspensions when charities break rules under the Income Tax Act. These sanctions depend on how serious the violation is.

Common penalties include monetary fines for specific violations. The CRA may also suspend a charity's ability to issue tax receipts for donations.

In severe cases, the CRA can revoke a charity's registered status completely. This means the charity loses all tax benefits and can no longer operate as a registered charity.

The CRA follows specific guidelines when deciding which sanctions to apply. They consider factors like whether the violation was intentional and how much harm it caused.

What do charities need to report in Canada?

Registered charities must file annual returns with the CRA that show their financial activities and charitable work. These returns include details about donations received and money spent on programs.

Charities must report how they spend their funds, including administrative costs and fundraising expenses. They need to show that most of their money goes to actual charitable activities.

Organizations must also report any changes to their structure, leadership, or charitable purposes. This includes updates to their board of directors and contact information.

All registered charities must keep detailed records of their activities. Certain information must be available to the public through the CRA's online database.

How to make an official complaint against revenue Canada in Canada?

You can file complaints about CRA service through the CRA's formal complaint process. This covers issues with how CRA staff treated you or handled your case.

For service complaints, start by calling the CRA and asking to speak with a supervisor about your concern. Clearly explain what went wrong and what you want fixed.

If the supervisor cannot resolve your complaint, you can request a formal review by the CRA's complaint handling process. This involves submitting written details about your experience.

For more serious issues, contact the Taxpayers' Ombudsperson, an independent office that investigates CRA service complaints from taxpayers and organizations.

How to call CRA from outside Canada?

You can reach the Charities Directorate from outside Canada by calling 1-613-957-8953. This is the international number for charity-related questions and concerns.

The phone lines operate during regular business hours in Eastern Time. Be prepared for longer wait times when calling from international locations.

Before calling, gather all relevant documents and information about your charity question or concern. This helps the call go more smoothly.

You can also use the CRA's online services and email options, which work from anywhere in the world with internet access.

How do I resolve a problem with CRA?

We start by calling the appropriate CRA phone line for our specific issue. For charity matters, we call the Charities Directorate at 1-800-267-2384.

We should have our charity registration number ready. We also gather all relevant documents before calling.

We explain our problem clearly. We ask for specific steps to fix it.

If the first person can't help, we ask to speak with a supervisor or specialist. We keep notes about who we talked to and what they told us.

For complex problems, we may need to submit written requests or extra documents. The CRA tells us what they need and when to submit it.

Who investigates non-profit organizations in Canada?

The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) Charities Directorate investigates tax compliance and charity-related violations.

Provincial Attorneys General investigate breaches of fiduciary duty and charitable property misuse. In Ontario, the Office of the Public Guardian and Trustee handles charitable property complaints.

Courts can order investigations for fraudulent or oppressive conduct when requested by corporation members.