August 11, 2022

How a Vancouver Charity Lost Everything Over a Date on a Form

Vancouver's Moon Gate Foundation lost its charitable status after issuing a $4.8 million donation receipt for shares that hadn't actually been transferred to the charity yet — a gap of 19 months, by which point the shares had lost 91% of their value.

The CRA ruled there was no legal gift on the date stated, the receipt showed the wrong date and wrong value, and the donor effectively received a massive tax benefit without ever parting with the shares.

The case is a sharp reminder that share donations are only complete — and receipts only valid — when the shares physically land in the charity's brokerage account.

Recent Podcasts