TL;DR: Under the Income Tax Act, the CRA may refuse to register a charity, suspend its receipting privileges for one year, or revoke its registration when an “ineligible individual” is a director, trustee, officer or like official, or controls or manages the charity directly or indirectly (ITA subsections 149.1(25) and 188.2(2) and paragraph 149.1(4.1)(e)). CRA Guidance CG-024 looks at real authority, not titles. A former director who still directs staff or moves money can put a charity’s registration at risk.
A director resigns. The minutes are updated. A new name goes on the paperwork. If that former director can still sign cheques, direct staff or overrule the board, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) can treat that person as still running the charity.
This article is for Ontario charity boards with a founder, pastor or former director who has a history at a revoked charity, and for boards about to recruit someone like that. It explains who counts as an ineligible individual, what the CRA can do, and what your board should check before the CRA asks.
An ineligible individual is a person who falls into one of the categories in the definition of “ineligible individual” in subsection 149.1(1) of the Income Tax Act. These rules came into force on January 1, 2012. The CRA explains how it applies them in Guidance CG-024, Ineligible individuals.
Five terms do most of the work:
For the revoked-charity categories, the five years run from the date of revocation, not from the breach or the date the person left.
Yes. The Income Tax Act does not prohibit an ineligible individual from serving as a director, employee or volunteer. CG-024 states that the Act gives the CRA discretion to act, and that the CRA assesses each case on its own merits, including whether safeguards protect the charity’s beneficiaries and assets.
CG-024 gives the example of a counselling charity whose board member, convicted of a similar offence to the people the charity serves, helps design effective programs. A charity can value that experience. If the CRA raises a concern, though, the burden is on the charity to explain the person’s role and the limits placed on it.
The CRA has three tools, and each one is discretionary. Under subsection 149.1(25), the CRA may refuse to register an applicant if an ineligible individual made the application, sits on the board, or controls or manages the organization. Under subsection 188.2(2), the CRA may suspend a registered charity’s receipting privileges for one year. Under paragraph 149.1(4.1)(e), the CRA may revoke a charity’s registration.
Before acting, the CRA sets out its concerns in writing and gives the charity a chance to respond. For applicants, CG-024 treats the person who submits the application through My Business Account, and any authorized representative who answers the CRA’s questions, as having made the application.
A resignation does not end the risk by itself. CG-024’s own example involves three directors who resigned when the CRA notified their charity of an audit. All three were still ineligible individuals for five years after the charity’s revocation, because they were directors when the serious breach occurred.
The second problem is practical. The CRA asks who controls or manages the charity today, not who appears on the board list. And if the CRA has already suspended receipting privileges, CG-024 states that the suspension lasts the full year even if the ineligible individual leaves.
On March 21, 2026, the Canada Gazette published the revocation of New Life Apostolic Ministries (Caledon), Assured Hope Ministry (Pickering) and Progressive Life Initiative Inc. (Niagara Falls). Each notice cited paragraph 149.1(4.1)(e) of the Income Tax Act.
Investigative Journalism Foundation reporter Bethany Lindsay reported that Ontario pastor Jermaine McLaughlin had been a director or authorized representative of six charities revoked after CRA audits. According to her reporting, the CRA considered him an ineligible individual in 2025 after three earlier revocations for cause, which involved concerns including false statements, private benefits to directors and inadequate books and records.
In all three 2026 files, the CRA said he held a position of control, through roles as authorized representative or director. At Assured Hope Ministry, the CRA also identified a second person it considered ineligible, who served as an officer. None of the three charities responded to the CRA.
Two lessons follow. The CRA did not need to show that the earlier misconduct happened again at the new charity. And silence cost each charity its registration. The CRA’s 2024–2025 Report on the Charities Program listed ineligible individuals among its top three high-risk compliance areas.
A board can tell who controls the charity by comparing its paperwork with how decisions actually get made. Ask:
If the answers do not match the organization chart, the answers are what the CRA will look at. The bank login can be more revealing than the letterhead.
A board that receives a credible warning should check the facts and limit the person’s authority before the CRA asks. A shared church affiliation or a rumour is not proof, but a prospective director who helped run a charity recently revoked for cause deserves a closer look.
The Income Tax Act does not require background checks. Insurers, provincial rules or work with vulnerable people may still require screening. Many charities also add an ineligible-individual declaration to their director consent form, which is a low-cost way to surface the issue at appointment.
An audit letter inviting a response is not the same as a notice of intention to revoke. Under subsection 168(2) of the Income Tax Act, the CRA can publish a revocation 30 days after mailing the notice unless the Federal Court of Appeal extends that period. Under subsection 168(4), a charity generally has 90 days from mailing to file an objection. Filing an objection does not stop publication. See our guide to charity revocation for what follows.
No. CG-024 states that the ineligible individual rules do not require criminal record or other background checks. Your insurer, provincial law or work with vulnerable people may still require them.
No. CG-024 states that a registered charity does not have to notify the CRA. The charity should still put safeguards in place to protect its beneficiaries and assets.
No. CG-024 states that the CRA will not provide pre-approval or clearance for any individual or organization.
It depends on the category. A person tied to a revoked charity is ineligible for five years from the revocation date. A relevant offence lasts five years from conviction. A relevant criminal offence lasts until a pardon or record suspension is in effect.
No. CG-024 states that CRA inaction is not an endorsement of any individual. Your board’s duty to protect the charity’s assets continues.
No. Being a founder, donor or clergy member does not by itself mean a person controls the charity. The CRA looks at actual powers, such as a veto over the board or authority over money and staff.
Compare your bank mandates, system permissions and staff reporting lines with the people your bylaws say are in charge. If they do not line up, or if the CRA has already written to you, book a charity governance and compliance review or schedule a free consultation with our team. For the wider legal duties of board members, see Charity Board of Directors: Legal Requirements and Best Practices in Canada.
The material provided on this website is for information purposes only.. You should not act or abstain from acting based upon such information without first consulting a Charity Lawyer. We do not warrant the accuracy or completeness of any information on this site. E-mail contact with anyone at B.I.G. Charity Law Group Professional Corporation is not intended to create, and receipt will not constitute, a solicitor-client relationship. Solicitor client relationship will only be created after we have reviewed your case or particulars, decided to accept your case and entered into a written retainer agreement or retainer letter with you.

DOV GOLDBERG, J.D. is a lawyer at B.I.G. Charity Law Group and has dedicated his career exclusively to Charity and Not-for-Profit Law for over a decade. Dov guides charities, foundations, and non-profit organizations through every stage of the registration process, offering practical legal advice with a focus on compliance, governance, and long-term success. Known for his hands-on approach and deep knowledge of CRA requirements, Dov is committed to helping clients build strong, sustainable, and legally sound organizations.