Ineligible Individuals: When the Charity Boardroom Door Closes, Who Still Holds the Keys?

Dov Goldberg

A director resigns. The minutes are updated. A new name goes on the charity's paperwork.

Problem solved?

Not necessarily. If the former director can still direct staff, control the bank account or overrule the board, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) may conclude that the person is still running the charity—whatever their title says.

That distinction matters under Canada's ineligible individual rules. In certain circumstances, the CRA can revoke a charity's registration if an ineligible individual is a director, trustee, officer or other governing official, or controls or manages the charity directly or indirectly.

Three Ontario revocations published in March 2026 offer a reminder for boards: knowing whose name is on the directors' list is only the beginning. The harder question is who actually holds the reins.

Six charities, two chapters

On March 21, 2026, three Ontario charities—New Life Apostolic Ministries, Assured Hope Ministry and Progressive Life Initiative Inc.—lost their charitable registrations. The notices published in the Canada Gazette cited the same provision of the Income Tax Act: paragraph 149.1(4.1)(e), which deals with ineligible individuals.

Investigative Journalism Foundation reporter Bethany Lindsay connected those revocations to an earlier group of cases. She reported that Ontario pastor Jermaine McLaughlin had been a director or authorized representative of six charities whose registrations were revoked following CRA audits during the period covered by her reporting.

The sequence is important.

According to Lindsay's reporting on the CRA's letters, the agency considered McLaughlin an ineligible individual in 2025 following three earlier revocations for cause. Across those earlier organizations, the audits cited concerns including false statements to maintain registration, private benefits to directors, inadequate books and records, and a failure to devote resources to charitable activities.

What the CRA said about the three charities

The CRA's notices described different roles at each organization:

New Life Apostolic Ministries, Caledon: The CRA listed McLaughlin as an authorized representative in its audit letter. In its notice of intention to revoke, the agency said he held a position of control and that the charity had not responded to its concern.

Assured Hope Ministry, Pickering: The CRA said two people it considered ineligible were in positions to control the charity: McLaughlin as an authorized representative and Christina Wong-McLaughlin as an officer. The CRA said the charity had not responded.

Progressive Life Initiative Inc., Niagara Falls: The CRA addressed its audit letter to McLaughlin as a director and its subsequent notice to him as an authorized representative. The agency said he occupied a position of control and that the charity had not responded.

The point for boards is significant. The CRA can take action because of who controls or manages a charity without first establishing that the conduct behind an earlier revocation happened again at the new organization. And the CRA appears to be making greater use of these rules.

Who is an ineligible individual?

The rules cover several categories, and the details matter. In particular, the five-year period does not apply in the same way to every category.

Relevant criminal convictions. There is no automatic five-year expiry. A conviction involving financial dishonesty or otherwise relevant to a charity's operations can result in ineligibility unless a pardon or record suspension has been granted and remains in effect.

Relevant non-criminal convictions. A qualifying non-criminal conviction can result in ineligibility for five years from the date of conviction. The offence must involve financial dishonesty or be relevant to the charity's operations. Foreign offences can also qualify under the applicable Canadian-equivalency tests for both conviction categories.

Leadership at a revoked charity or registered Canadian amateur athletic association. A person may be ineligible if they held a qualifying office or controlled or managed the organization when a serious breach occurred and the organization's registration was later revoked. The five years run from the revocation, not from the breach or the person's departure. The CRA says a routine revocation for failing to file a return would not normally count as a serious breach for this purpose.

Tax shelter promotion. A promoter may be ineligible for five years after a charity or registered Canadian amateur athletic association loses its registration where the reasons for revocation included or related to its participation in the tax shelter.

The statute also covers certain connections to listed terrorist entities; those connections were not the basis described in the reporting on the Ontario cases.

The legal time limit is only part of the board's decision. A person whose five-year period has ended may still be a poor choice for treasurer if their past conduct involved serious receipting abuse. The end of statutory ineligibility does not require a board to overlook what happened.

A resignation changes the minutes. Does it change who has power?

The CRA looks at what people actually do, not just what their business cards say.

Its guidance gives the example of a member of the clergy who has significant influence over a board or a veto over its decisions. Even without a formal title in the charity's governing documents, that person could be considered a "like official." The CRA also considers practical powers, such as the ability to reverse board decisions, prepare budgets, or hire and dismiss staff.

Context matters. Calling someone an "adviser" does not settle whether they have control. Equally, being a founder, donor, clergy member or authorized contact does not, by itself, establish that someone governs or manages an existing charity.

A board trying to understand the real picture might ask:

  • Who can authorize payments or access the bank account?
  • Who can issue official donation receipts?
  • Who directs staff?
  • Who can change a bank mandate?
  • Who can get a board decision reversed?

If those answers do not match the organization chart, pay attention to the answers. The bank login can be more revealing than the letterhead.

The rules are also more flexible than their name might suggest. They do not impose a blanket ban on every ineligible individual serving or working for a charity. Depending on the circumstances, the CRA may refuse an application, suspend receipting privileges for one year or revoke registration where an ineligible individual occupies a qualifying role.

The CRA says it assesses each case on its merits, including whether safeguards protect the charity's beneficiaries and assets. Its guidance gives the example of a rehabilitation program that benefits from the insight of people with experience in the justice system. A charity can value that contribution while placing appropriate limits on the person's authority and access.

What should a board do when a concern arises?

The ineligible-individual rules do not require every charity to conduct blanket background checks. And most charities do not need elaborate policies or annual attestations.

A credible warning, however, deserves a closer look. If a prospective director helped run an organization that recently lost its registration for cause, the board should not simply hope for the best.

1. Establish the facts. Find out why the earlier registration was revoked, when the revocation took effect and what role the person held when the relevant conduct occurred. Keep the inquiry proportionate and confidential. A shared affiliation—or a rumour—is not proof.

2. Address actual authority. Where the risk warrants it, independent directors should consider transferring signing authority, removing relevant system access and clarifying who can direct staff or approve transactions. If the person remains involved in a limited capacity, define the boundaries and assign someone to check that they are being respected.

3. Keep evidence that the controls work. A board resolution is a start. Updated bank mandates, system permissions and records of independent review help show what changed in practice. The CRA identifies minutes, financial-control policies and transaction records as examples of relevant evidence.

4. Respond if the CRA writes. Address the alleged basis for ineligibility, the person's actual role and any safeguards. If the board disagrees with the CRA's account, say precisely what it disputes and provide supporting records.

Other legal, safeguarding or insurance requirements may call for separate screening, even where the ineligible-individual rules do not.

If the CRA has issued a notice, watch the clock

An audit letter inviting a response is not the same thing as a formal notice of intention to revoke.

If a formal notice arrives, obtain advice promptly. The Income Tax Act generally allows 90 days from mailing to object, but publication of the revocation can occur after 30 days unless the Federal Court of Appeal extends that period. Filing an objection alone does not stop publication.

One question for your next board meeting

Who can commit the charity's money, issue receipts, direct staff or override a board decision—and what evidence shows that the board can take that authority back?

Compare the answers with the bank mandates, system permissions and staff reporting lines. If they do not line up, your board has found something worth fixing.

This article is for general information and is not legal advice. A charity facing a specific eligibility concern or CRA notice should seek Canadian charity-law advice.

The material provided on this website is for information purposes only. It is not intended to be legal advice. You should not act or abstain from acting based upon such information without first consulting a Charity Lawyer. We do not warrant the accuracy or completeness of any information on this site. E-mail contact with anyone at B.I.G. Charity Law Group Professional Corporation is not intended to create, and receipt will not constitute, a solicitor-client relationship. Solicitor client relationship will only be created after we have reviewed your case or particulars, decided to accept your case and entered into a written retainer agreement or retainer letter with you.

DOV GOLDBERG, J.D.

DOV GOLDBERG, J.D. is a lawyer at B.I.G. Charity Law Group and has dedicated his career exclusively to Charity and Not-for-Profit Law for over a decade. Dov guides charities, foundations, and non-profit organizations through every stage of the registration process, offering practical legal advice with a focus on compliance, governance, and long-term success. Known for his hands-on approach and deep knowledge of CRA requirements, Dov is committed to helping clients build strong, sustainable, and legally sound organizations.