How Does the CRA Interpret Accountability Requirements for Grants to Non-Qualified Donees?

Dov Goldberg

TL;DR: Under subsection 149.1(1) of the Income Tax Act, a registered charity may grant money or other resources to a non-qualified donee only if three things are true:

  • the grant furthers one of the charity's own charitable purposes;
  • the charity ensures the resources are used exclusively for charitable activities that further that purpose;
  • the charity keeps documentation proving both.

CRA Guidance CG-032 (issued December 19, 2023) interprets these accountability requirements through a risk-based due diligence model. The riskier the grant, the more research, written terms, reporting and records the CRA expects.

Who do the accountability requirements apply to?

The requirements apply when your charity makes a grant to a non-qualified donee: any person or organization that is not a qualified donee under the Income Tax Act. Qualified donees include other registered charities and the other entities listed in CRA Guidance CG-010. Since Bill C-19 received Royal Assent on June 23, 2022, the Act has allowed a grant to a non-qualified donee (which the Act calls a "grantee organization") to count as a qualifying disbursement, meaning a permitted use of charitable resources.

These rules govern grants your charity makes, not grants it receives. A government or foundation grant your charity receives comes with that funder's own conditions.

The Act sets three accountability requirements for every grant to a grantee:

  1. The grant furthers a charitable purpose stated in your charity's governing document.
  2. Your charity ensures the grant is applied exclusively to charitable activities that further that purpose.
  3. Your charity maintains documentation sufficient to show the grant's purpose and that the grantee applied it exclusively to that purpose.

CG-032 separates these legal requirements from accountability tools, which are the due diligence steps the CRA recommends for meeting them. CG-032 is not law. A charity can use other measures, provided its books and records show it met the three statutory requirements. The guidance and the official CRA overview are at Registered charities making grants to non-qualified donees (CG-032).

Does your charity's purpose allow the grant?

A grant is permitted only if it furthers a charitable purpose already stated in your governing document. It is not enough that the grant is charitable in general. CG-032 gives an example of a suitable purpose: advancing education by providing books, equipment and educational aids to students.

Your charity may need to amend its purposes before granting in two situations:

  • the grant would serve a purpose your governing document does not state;
  • your charity has no stated purpose within the four categories of charity.

The second situation catches foundations whose only purpose is to make gifts to qualified donees. A purpose to "make grants" is not charitable on its own, so adding one does not solve the problem.

We regularly see family and community foundations assume they can start granting to non-qualified donees immediately. They then discover that their governing documents restrict them strictly to “gifting funds to qualified donees.” Amending your corporate purposes requires filing Articles of Amendment under your governing corporate statute. You also have to file the change with the CRA, together with detailed activities in support of the new mandates. Boards should start this process well before committing to a grant.

For help checking alignment, see our article on ensuring grant activities align with your charity's purpose.

How does the CRA decide how much due diligence a grant needs?

CG-032 asks you to rate each grant as low, medium or high risk, then scale your due diligence to match. The risk factors include:

  • your charity's experience with grants;
  • the grantee's experience, governance and regulatory oversight;
  • how closely the grantee's purposes align with yours;
  • any private benefit concerns;
  • where the activity takes place;
  • the type of resources granted;
  • the grant's length;
  • the grant's size: up to $5,000 points to low risk, more than $5,000 up to $50,000 to medium risk, and more than $50,000 to high risk.

Cash, cryptocurrency and real property sit at the high end. Charitable goods such as textbooks or medical supplies sit at the low end. You should reassess the risk rating whenever conditions change, such as a leadership change at the grantee or a decline in security where the work happens.

‍

Accountability tool Low risk Medium risk High risk
Research and review of grantee Limited, especially with an existing relationship Moderate, such as independent research Extensive, such as information requests or a site visit
Description of grant activity Simple Written, covering key elements Detailed and written
Written agreement Simple; emails or minutes may do for one-time grants of $5,000 or less Formal, with key terms Formal, with comprehensive terms
Reporting plan Simple final report Final report on key deliverables, plus interim reports if useful Detailed final report, plus interim reports where appropriate
Transfer schedule Optional If the charity has concerns Yes, unless instalments are impossible
Separately tracked funds Simple ledger Ledger of key elements Detailed records

‍

Source: CRA Guidance CG-032, section 3.3.2 (summarized).

Do you need a written grant agreement?

For most grants, yes. CG-032 recommends a written agreement because the Act requires you to document each grant's purpose. A written agreement may not be necessary for a one-time grant of $5,000 or less in very low-risk circumstances, where emails and meeting minutes can serve as the record. If you expect to give the same grantee $5,000 or less every year, the CRA still recommends an agreement.

A sound agreement typically includes:

  • a statement that the arrangement is a grant, not an intermediary arrangement;
  • the parties' full legal names and the start and end dates;
  • the activity, its location, and the charitable purpose it furthers;
  • reporting deadlines;
  • the right to pay in instalments, to terminate, and to recover unused funds;
  • a requirement that the grantee track your grant separately in its own books.

In the draft grant agreements we review, three clauses are missing most often:

  1. a strict requirement that the grantee immediately return any unused or misapplied funds on demand;
  2. a milestone-based instalment holdback schedule tied to the charity's review and approval of interim reports;
  3. an explicit prohibition against the grantee re-granting the funds or using them for partisan political or non-charitable activities.

What records must your charity keep?

Section 230(2) of the Income Tax Act requires every registered charity to keep adequate books and records in Canada. For grants, those records must let the CRA verify three things:

  • the grant met the accountability requirements;
  • the grantee's use of the resources can be checked;
  • the resources are still being used as agreed.

CG-032 recommends requiring a final written report for every grant, with interim reports for longer or higher-risk grants. File the report along with a note that your board reviewed it. Our guide to keeping proper books and records covers the general rules.

How do you report grants on the T3010?

Under section 3703 of the Income Tax Regulations, a charity that grants a total of more than $5,000 to one grantee in a taxation year must report the grantee's name, the purpose of each grant, and the total amount. You file these details on Form T1441, Qualifying Disbursements: Grants to Non-Qualified Donees with your T3010 Registered Charity Information Return.

Grantees that received $5,000 or less in total are reported only as a total count and a total amount. Names reported for grantees over $5,000 become public. A charity can ask the CRA to withhold information if releasing it would endanger people involved. Non-cash grants are reported at fair market value.

What happens if your charity gets it wrong?

A charity that does not meet the accountability requirements could jeopardize its registration. Depending on how serious the problem is, CRA responses range from education letters and compliance agreements to sanctions and, in the most severe cases, revocation under section 168 of the Income Tax Act.

A separate risk is the directed-gift rule. Under paragraph 168(1)(f), registration can be revoked if your charity accepts a donation on the condition that it be passed to a specific non-qualified donee. Your charity must keep final authority over how donations are used.

We advise charities to place an explicit donor disclosure directly above the payment button on their donation pages. The disclosure should say that the charity welcomes a donor's preference for a specific program, but that all donations are made to the charity unconditionally. It should also say that the board keeps absolute discretion and control over the use of all funds. Finally, it should say that gifts are not refundable if the board redirects the funds to another charitable activity within that program area.

Should your charity grant, gift, or use an intermediary?

You have three routes:

  • Gift to a qualified donee. This is the simplest route when the recipient is itself a registered charity.
  • Grant to a non-qualified donee. This lets the grantee run its own program, subject to the accountability requirements.
  • Own activities through an intermediary. Your charity carries on its own activity through the intermediary under direction and control, as set out in CRA Guidance CG-002 and CG-004.

Decide which route you are using at the start and record the choice. Our article on the CRA grant regime versus direction and control compares the last two in detail.

Frequently asked questions

Does our charity need a written agreement for every grant to a non-qualified donee?

CG-032 recommends one for most grants. A one-time grant of $5,000 or less in very low-risk circumstances may be documented through emails and minutes instead.

Can a foundation whose only purpose is gifting to qualified donees make grants?

Not without amending its purposes. Under CG-032, the grant must further a charitable purpose in the foundation's governing document, and a gifting-only or grant-making purpose does not qualify.

Do we have to report grants to non-qualified donees publicly?

Yes, when your charity grants more than $5,000 in total to one grantee in a year. The grantee's name, the grant purpose and the amount go on Form T1441 with the T3010 and are published.

Can a donor choose which non-qualified donee receives their donation?

A donor can state a preference, but your charity must keep final authority over how the funds are used. Accepting a gift conditional on passing it to a specific non-qualified donee can lead to revocation under paragraph 168(1)(f) of the Income Tax Act.

Is there a limit on how much a charitable organization can grant to non-qualified donees?

No. Making grants to non-qualified donees does not trigger re-designation as a foundation, provided the charity continues to meet the definition of a charitable organization under subsection 149.1(1) and complies with subsection 149.1(6.001).

Can we switch an existing intermediary relationship to a grant?

Yes. CG-032 allows a charity to convert an intermediary relationship to a grant, or the reverse, provided it meets all requirements at the time of the change and records the switch in its books.

What should your board do next?

Before approving your next grant to a non-charity partner, take these three steps:

  1. Confirm your governing document covers the grant's purpose.
  2. Rate the grant's risk.
  3. Put the matching agreement and reporting terms in writing.

If your purposes need amending or you are setting up a granting policy, our charity governance and compliance team can review your documents. You can also book a free consultation with Dov Goldberg.

The material provided on this website is for information purposes only. It is not intended to be legal advice. You should not act or abstain from acting based upon such information without first consulting a Charity Lawyer. We do not warrant the accuracy or completeness of any information on this site. E-mail contact with anyone at B.I.G. Charity Law Group Professional Corporation is not intended to create, and receipt will not constitute, a solicitor-client relationship. Solicitor client relationship will only be created after we have reviewed your case or particulars, decided to accept your case and entered into a written retainer agreement or retainer letter with you.

DOV GOLDBERG, J.D.

DOV GOLDBERG, J.D. is a lawyer at B.I.G. Charity Law Group and has dedicated his career exclusively to Charity and Not-for-Profit Law for over a decade. Dov guides charities, foundations, and non-profit organizations through every stage of the registration process, offering practical legal advice with a focus on compliance, governance, and long-term success. Known for his hands-on approach and deep knowledge of CRA requirements, Dov is committed to helping clients build strong, sustainable, and legally sound organizations.