Incorporated Is Not Registered: The Gap Between ONCA Incorporation and CRA Charity Status

Dov Goldberg

TL;DR: Incorporating under Ontario's Not-for-Profit Corporations Act, 2010 (ONCA) creates a not-for-profit corporation. Only registration by the Canada Revenue Agency under section 149.1 of the Income Tax Act makes it a "registered charity" that can issue official donation receipts. ServiceOntario does not check whether your purposes are charitable; CRA does, usually after the corporation already exists.

If you have just received your Ontario certificate, you have a corporation with charitable purposes. You do not yet have a registered charity. A few terms explain the difference:

  • A registered charity is an organization CRA has registered under the Income Tax Act. The term is defined in subsection 248(1).
  • An official donation receipt is the receipt a donor uses to claim a tax credit. Only a registered charity can issue one.
  • A charitable purpose is a purpose the law recognizes as charitable, which is narrower than the everyday meaning of "charity."
  • Charitable special provisions are clauses Ontario adds to a charity's articles, binding it to charity law from day one.

What is the difference between incorporating and registering a charity?

‍

Ontario incorporation CRA charitable registration
Who decides ServiceOntario, under the ONCA CRA Charities Directorate, under the Income Tax Act
What you get A legal entity with limited liability A registration number and the ability to issue official donation receipts
Government fee $155 None
Review of purposes None Detailed review of purposes and activities
Guaranteed? Yes, if the filing is complete No

‍

Ontario's Not-for-Profit Incorporator's Handbook states that incorporating a charity does not guarantee CRA registration. CRA also weighs the registration application and the organization's financial information.

CRA's official service standard is nine months from receipt of a complete application. In our recent experience, though, many registrations are coming through in just three months. Our 2026 charity registration and revocation statistics track the trend, and our guide on how long it takes to register a charity in Canada explains what moves an application faster.

Why doesn't the Ontario certificate settle whether your purposes are charitable?

Since the ONCA came into force on October 19, 2021, the Public Guardian and Trustee (PGT) no longer reviews a new charity's purposes before incorporation. ServiceOntario's Notice on incorporating a not-for-profit says incorporation does not guarantee CRA will accept the purposes as charitable. The handbook adds that the PGT cannot review or help draft charitable purposes.

The cost of a weak purpose clause has therefore moved later in the process. A problem that once surfaced before incorporation now surfaces during CRA review. By then the organization has usually opened a bank account, recruited a board and announced itself. Fixing the purposes at that point means filing Articles of Amendment, at a current fee of $130, and updating the CRA application.

What makes a purpose charitable in law?

In Vancouver Society of Immigrant and Visible Minority Women v. M.N.R., [1999] 1 S.C.R. 10, the Supreme Court of Canada confirmed that a charitable purpose must fall under one of four heads:

  • relief of poverty;
  • advancement of education;
  • advancement of religion;
  • other purposes beneficial to the community that the courts have recognized as charitable, such as promoting health or protecting the environment.

Each purpose must also deliver a public benefit to the community or a sufficient section of it. Every purpose must be exclusively charitable. A corporation with one non-charitable purpose is not a charity.

Why do charitable purposes fail at CRA?

The handbook's drafting principles track the most common problems:

  • Vague words. "Philanthropic," "benevolent," "patriotic" and "public" purposes are often too vague to qualify.
  • Listing the four heads. Reproducing the heads of charity without saying what the organization will do is not acceptable.
  • Private benefit. Raising money for one named person is not charitable. Funding research into that person's illness, or support for people living with it, can be.
  • Fundraising as a purpose. Charities can fundraise, but fundraising is not a purpose in itself.
  • Promoting a sport. In A.Y.S.A. Amateur Youth Soccer Association, 2007 SCC 42, the Supreme Court held that promoting a sport is not charitable in itself. Registering as a Canadian amateur athletic association (RCAAA) is not an automatic fallback. A typical local sports group will not qualify, because an RCAAA's exclusive purpose and function must be promoting amateur athletics in Canada on a nationwide basis. A sports group must either meet CRA's RCAAA requirements or revise its purposes so they are charitable, as in the hockey example below. Our guide on how to start a charity sports organization covers the options.
  • Political purposes. A purpose of changing the law usually will not qualify. A charity can, however, carry on public policy dialogue and development activities that further its charitable purposes under subsections 149.1(6.1) and (6.2) of the Income Tax Act, as CRA explains in guidance CG-027.
  • Members' interests. An organization that mainly promotes its own members' interests usually will not qualify.

What does a stronger purpose look like?

These examples are illustrative only. For more worked examples, see our guide to getting your charitable purposes right.

‍

Weak purpose Problem Stronger direction
"To promote youth hockey in Brampton" Promoting a sport is not charitable in itself An education or disability-relief purpose delivered through adapted programs for a defined group
"To help the community" Too vague A specific activity for specific beneficiaries under a recognized head of charity
"To raise funds for Maria's cancer treatment" Private benefit Support programs for people living with cancer, or funding cancer research
"To advance education, relieve poverty and promote health" Lists the heads only Describe how and for whom the organization will do each

‍

Can you use CRA's model purposes?

Yes, as long as CRA's model purposes accurately describe what you will actually do.

For example, a charity incorporates with one template purpose: operating a soup kitchen. Two years later a funder offers a grant for a job-readiness program for the same clients. The new program falls outside the soup-kitchen purpose, so the charity must amend its articles before it can accept and spend the grant. The handbook warns that directors who spend a charity's funds outside its purposes can be ordered by a court to repay them. Draft purposes for the programs you expect to run over the next two to three years, not just the first one. Our article on charitable purposes vs. activities explains why the two must line up.

What happens if CRA refuses to register you?

You can generally revise your purposes, amend your articles and continue the application. If registration fails altogether, your corporation is still a charitable corporation under Ontario law. The special provisions Ontario added at incorporation make it subject to the Charities Accounting Act and require its remaining property to go to a registered charity with similar purposes, the Crown or a municipality on dissolution. Founders cannot simply take the money back or redirect it to a non-charitable project.

In what order should you incorporate and apply?

  1. Draft purposes against your actual activities for the first two to three years.
  2. Test them against CRA's guidance on charitable purposes, or have a charity lawyer review them, before filing articles.
  3. If you will run a regulated program, such as child care or health services, consult the responsible ministry.
  4. Incorporate through the Ontario Business Registry, indicating the corporation will operate as a charity so the charitable special provisions are added.
  5. Pass an organizational by-law within 60 days, or the Ministry's standard by-law is deemed to apply.
  6. Apply to become a registered charity using CRA's online form in My Business Account. Our step-by-step guide on how to register a charity in Canada walks through the application.
  7. Do not issue receipts or accept restricted gifts on the assumption that registration will follow.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the PGT approve new charity incorporations in Ontario?

No. Ontario charities incorporate directly through ServiceOntario, and the PGT does not review their purposes at that stage.

Can we issue tax receipts once we're incorporated?

No. Only a registered charity, as defined in subsection 248(1) of the Income Tax Act, can issue official donation receipts.

Do we have to use CRA's model purposes?

No. They are optional. Whatever purposes you use, model or custom, must accurately describe your activities.

What happens if CRA rejects our purposes?

You will generally need to amend your articles and continue the application with revised purposes. The current ONCA amendment fee is $130.

Can a nonprofit that isn't a charity still be tax-exempt?

Yes, possibly. A non-profit organization under paragraph 149(1)(l) of the Income Tax Act can be exempt from income tax, but it cannot issue official donation receipts.

Should we incorporate federally or in Ontario?

It depends on where you will operate. A charity incorporated federally under the Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act that operates or holds property in Ontario must still comply with Ontario charity law. Our comparison of CNCA vs. ONCA explains the trade-offs.

What should you do before you file?

Have your purposes reviewed before the articles go to ServiceOntario, because changing them after incorporation costs time and a filing fee. Book a free consultation with our charity lawyers or call 416-488-5888.

The material provided on this website is for information purposes only. It is not intended to be legal advice. You should not act or abstain from acting based upon such information without first consulting a Charity Lawyer. We do not warrant the accuracy or completeness of any information on this site. E-mail contact with anyone at B.I.G. Charity Law Group Professional Corporation is not intended to create, and receipt will not constitute, a solicitor-client relationship. Solicitor client relationship will only be created after we have reviewed your case or particulars, decided to accept your case and entered into a written retainer agreement or retainer letter with you.

DOV GOLDBERG, J.D.

DOV GOLDBERG, J.D. is a lawyer at B.I.G. Charity Law Group and has dedicated his career exclusively to Charity and Not-for-Profit Law for over a decade. Dov guides charities, foundations, and non-profit organizations through every stage of the registration process, offering practical legal advice with a focus on compliance, governance, and long-term success. Known for his hands-on approach and deep knowledge of CRA requirements, Dov is committed to helping clients build strong, sustainable, and legally sound organizations.