In this episode, we break down why a private foundation can make its directors a fantastic financial return on a loan and still lose its charitable status entirely.
We use a nearly 40-year-old Ontario case, the Feldman Charitable Foundation, where a director's company borrowed almost the entire foundation's assets, paid it back in full with no losses, and the board still got hit with a finding that it breached its fiduciary duty.
We unpack why the CRA and the courts do not care about the return on investment and instead scrutinize process: who negotiated the deal, whether the foundation had genuinely independent legal advice, whether directors left the room during the vote, and whether the board's reasoning was actually written down.